Animal Protection > Actions - Index > China
Finally, Outrage in China Against Bear Farming

February 20, 2012

Scientific Studies Reveal Brutal Truth of Bear Farming Industry SHOCKING VIDEO.

A caged cub at a bear bile farm in Hanoi, Vietnam. M. Silverberg/TRAFFIC
Southeast Asia, via Associated Press

A caged cub at a bear bile farm in Hanoi, Vietnam.

HONG KONG - Walk into a barn lined with cramped bear cages and you hear two kinds of sounds from the animals - either a high-pitched whimper or a deep, raging snarl.

It's a distasteful experience, and saddening, watching a keeper stab anesthesia into a thrashing bear, then locate the groggy animal's gall bladder with a small sonogram machine and withdraw a fat hypodermic's worth of bile. It's not for the squeamish.

The practice is gruesome enough that hundreds of thousands of Chinese have attacked the pharmaceutical company Guizhentang with online complaints over the firm's plans to triple the size of its bear-bile farms through a public offering of shares on the Shenzhen stock exchange. The company said it currently farms about 400 bears.

The company also said its Web site was hacked last Saturday, one hour after it posted an invitation for the public to visit its bear farm.

Outrage does seem to be growing in China. The former N.B.A. star Yao Ming recently visited and endorsed a sanctuary run by the Animals Asia Foundation near Chengdu, in Sichuan Province. The group estimates that about 20,000 black bears are kept on about 100 bile farms in China.

The Ta Foundation, a private animal welfare group, recently submitted a petition to the Chinese regulatory authorities signed by 72 public figures, including Ding Junhui, a famous Chinese snooker player, Chen Danqing, a well-known painter, and Cui Yongyuan, a TV host.

The comedian Ricky Gervais also has been a longtime supporter of campaigns to stop bile farms. Earlier this month a rescue bear he sponsored died.

Bear bile is prized in traditional Chinese medicine for its alleged ability to relieve muscle aches, joint pains, fever, migraines and hangovers, as well as being a curative for impotence, gallstones, cirrhosis, even cancer. Synthetic compounds are just as effective for many of these ailments, but many Asians, especially Chinese and Vietnamese men of a certain age, favor fresh bile. Drops of newly extracted bile or flakes of bile powder are typically added to rice wine.

I saw the bile-milking at a bear farming operation outside Hanoi. A dozen or so Vietnamese buyers were there, too - intent on watching the process to ensure their bile would be as fresh as possible. The whole thing was illegal, but hardly secret.

The farm office was a windowless concrete room with a couple of battered couches and an old TV. On a sideboard, a dozen large glass jugs of rice wine were on display - with amputated bear paws marinating inside. Resting at the bottom of one container, barely visible in the cloudy sediment, was a tiny bear fetus. A vial of bear bile powder from the Chinese company Guizhentang Pharmaceuticals Co.

Asiatic black bears - they're also known as moon bears for the crescent of white on their chests - can grow to 400 pounds or more, but the cages at the Hanoi farm were just 4 feet by 5 feet, and most were not high enough for the bears to stand up.

The head of the Chinese Association of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Fang Shuting, said last week that "bile extraction doesn't harm bears."

Wildlife biologists vehemently disagree, saying the needle sticks, catheterization and repeated draining of the gall bladder creates infections and leakage, which can lead to peritonitis and septicemia. "An excruciating death,'' said one scientist.

"The process of extracting bear bile is like turning on a tap: natural, easy and without pain,'' Mr. Fang insisted. "After they're done, the bears can even play happily outside. I don't think there's anything out of the ordinary! It might even be a very comfortable process!"

A commenter on the popular Chinese microblogging site Sina Weibo said: "I don't believe it at all that extracting bile is as easy and comfortable as Fang said. Why doesn't he extract the bile from his body in the same way to prove it?"

A video of a bile extraction - on Shanghaiist, via the Chinese sharing site Youku - is here.

The bear milking I saw outside Hanoi in 2002 was horrifying.

The owner of the Vietnamese operation, Nguyen Hong Ha, told me he was expanding his operation. He had just ordered 10 new bears to be smuggled in from Laos at a cost of $6,000 each. Asked how he circumvented anti-trafficking regulations, he smiled and said, "I have a brother in the Forestry Department." The department was supposedly in charge of catching animal traders and policing the bear farms.

With a dozen local buyers looking on, Mr. Ha's workers tranquilized a highly agitated 5-year-old female bear. They then rolled her onto her back and bound her, spread-eagled, with ropes and cords. Using a toaster-size ultrasound machine, they located the gall bladder, stuck in a 7-inch syringe and slowly withdrew about a quarter-pint of bile. The whole procedure took 15 minutes.

Mr. Ha's take for the morning from the one female was $800 - more than twice the average annual salary in Vietnam at the time. If he milks his 45 bears five times a year, Ha said he would gross $180,000, a fortune in Vietnam.

And even if the milking procedures reduced a bear's life expectancy from 24 years to seven or eight, Mr. Ha figured he could add to his profit by hacking off the occasional paw to sell to a restaurant.

In one section of his farm, five of the 14 caged bears had paws missing. One bear, a big male, was missing two. nst-bear-farming/

Retired basketball superstar Yao Ming pets a bear at the Longqiao Bear Rescue Center in Southwest China's Sichuan province on Saturday morning. The center rescued the bear from a factory that extracts bile from live captive bears to make traditional Chinese medicines. China Daily/Asia News Network Monday, Feb 20, 2012

BEIJING - A Chinese pharmaceutical company invited the public to visit its bear-bile farms to clear up concerns about maltreatment, but soon found that its website had been hacked.

Its move also drew questions and criticism from animal protection organizations.

Fujian Guizhentang Pharmaceuticals Co Ltd, which extracts bear bile to make traditional Chinese medicines, had been planning a stock market listing.

The plan was strongly opposed by animal protection organizations and many individuals who accused it of using cruelty to extract bile from bears.

The company claimed that the animal rights groups had no idea of current extraction methods, which were "easy and not hurtful", and it announced plans to open its farm to visits by media and experts on Wednesday and Friday.

In a public invitation posted on its website, the company said it expected to receive 100 people - media on Wednesday and experts on Friday - and let them see the living conditions of its captive bears and the process of extraction.

But within an hour after the invitation was posted on Saturday night, the website was hacked.

"It was repaired in the morning and we've reopened registration for everybody interested in this issue. The list of those who received an invitation is expected to be posted on the website on Sunday night," a female employee who said she was in charge of collecting information about visits told China Daily on Sunday.

But some celebrities and experts said that they had doubts about the public visits.

Zhang Yue, a TV hostess and founder of the Beijing Loving Animals Foundation, also known as Ta Foundation, said that although the visits represented progress by the company, she and the organization rejected such 'staged' events.

"We all know that the company could have time to prepare for the visits and may give the public a false picture," she said. "What we want is the truth."

Media and experts should not visit on two separate days, because it wouldn't help reporters learn the truth, she said.

Officials from the World Society for the Protection of Animals, headquartered in London, also said that the visits wouldn't reveal the truth.

Sun Quanhui, a senior official of the society, said: "The visits won't help people get a true and full picture about the captive bears These short visits would only provide a superficial view. We cannot guarantee what we will see is true."

He suggested that instead of a couple of visits of this nature, there should be a series of visits based on a systematic plan to evaluate the bears' situation and the method of extracting bile.

Not only domestic experts should have a chance to visit, he added. Involving international experts would make the results more credible.

The matter also attracted online attention. A netizen named 8arbara posted on Sina weibo, a popular micro-blogging website: "It's too cruel to witness the extraction of bile from a pipe plugged into a bear's body.

"I don't believe we'd see the real situation in just those two days," she said.

Guizhentang, founded in 2000, keeps 470 bears and may expand the size of its farm after raising funds through its initial public offering (IPO).

But its attempt to get listed has aroused much controversy. More than 80 public figures have signed a petition opposing its IPO application.

"We'll make more effort to stop its application (for a listing) and force the company to stop maltreating those bears at last," Zhang said. or A1Story20120220-328957.html

Fair Use Notice and Disclaimer
Send questions or comments about this web site to Ann Berlin,