full story, photos, comments:
Footage from German and Italian labs makes its way to television reports.
22 December 2014
A protester outside the Max Planck Institute holds a toy monkey nailed to a
cross and a sign reading 'Died for humanity' on 20 December.
Activists calling for an end to research using non-human primates have stepped
up activities in Germany and Italy.
An estimated 800 animal-rights activists demonstrated in front of the Max Planck
Institute for Biological Cybernetics in Tübingen, Germany, on 20 December,
calling for an end to the research with monkeys that takes place there. A
smaller group maintained an all-night vigil.
Friedrich Mülln, head of the activist group SOKO Tierschutz, which organized the
action, told Nature that the group would continue actions against the institute
next year "until the department that does this research is closed down."
In September, SOKO Tierschutz, which is based in Augsburg, Germany, posted a
video on its website that included material filmed secretly in the institute by
a former animal carer. The footage was used in a television report that claimed
malpractice in the laboratory, but a preliminary investigation commissioned in
response by the Max Planck Society did not reveal systematic problems in animal
welfare. The society says that the Tübingen scientists contribute importantly to
global research efforts to understand the human brain.
In a similar undercover operation, an anonymous person took smartphone footage
of caged monkeys in a primate laboratory at the Sapienza University of Rome. The
popular show Striscia la
Notizia, which mixes exposé with entertainment, used the footage in an 18
December report which claimed that scientists at the university conducted their
work in secret and without oversight. The TV report also said that its producers
contacted the Italian ministry of health and the local health office, and that
neither was able to explain what the lab's experiments are about.
The university denies the accusations of lack of transparency and oversight.
"The methodological details and the scientific results of all experiments are
published in international scientific journals that are archived and searchable
in the PubMed database of scientific literature," it said in a statement. It
added that the laboratory keeps records of its use of animals and is subjected
to periodic inspections from the ministry of health and the local health office.
Italy is generally seen as a strict enforcer of European Union directives on the
use of animals in research (see 'Biomedicine:
The changing face of primate research').
Monica di Luca, a pharmacologist at the University of Milan, Italy, and
president of the Federation of European Neuroscience Societies, says that the
intensifying activity against researchers in Europe is "worrying". Research
using non-human primates is essential in efforts to cure psychiatric and
neurological disorders such as Alzheimer's disease, she says. Politicians are
asking scientists for results, she says, "but we won't be able to respond
efficiently if pressures on researchers get too high".