GEVHA/Autonomous University of Barcelona
presented at the American Society of
Criminology conference a paper that linked animal cruelty with
anti-social personality disorder. The event was held in Chicago from
November 14 to 17 and the abstract presented was titled
"Cruelty to Animals and Antisocial Personality Disorder: Criminology and
Forensic Correlations" with the following session description:
"Animal mistreatment is often related to affective and link disorders within
interpersonal relationships concerning underage people whose lack of empathy
and remorse, associated with behavior disorders, are personality traits
which imply probable violence in adulthood (Ascione, 2001). In our study
fifty adult forensic cases (49 men, average age 34), in which there's a
history of animal mistreatment as an independent variable, and the dependent
variables are: (a) crime committed (violent/ non-violent); (b) presence or
not of two dimensional psychopathy factors (PCL:SV; Hare 1985), and APD
(DSM-IV-TR); (c) McDonald triad (cruelty to animals, pyromania, night
urinary incontinence) and Pincus triad (child abuse, brain injury, paranoid
ideation), and (d) kind of animal mistreatment in childhood-adolescence. The
results show a 70% violent crimes in batterers of animals as the cause of
their prosecution (56% in their crime history), a clearly antisocial profile
(APD) or factor 2 of psychopathy (rather than nuclear psychopathy), with a
McDonald triad prevalence of 48% and 30% of Pincus triad. These results show
the need to assess the possible childhood and adolescence cruelty to animals
in individuals whose violent behavior include crime in adulthood."
The organization also presented a similar paper in Sweden at the
2012 Stockholm Criminology
Symposium in June. The Swedish presentation was titled
"The Role of Animals in Domestic Violence", with the following session
description:
"Regarding violence to animals within the context of
domestic violence, previous studies reveal that 71% of pet-owning women
entering women's shelters reported that their batterer had injured, maimed,
killed or threatened family pets for revenge or to psychologically control
victims; 32% reported their children had hurt or killed animals. 68% of
battered women reported violence towards their animals. 87% of these
incidents occurred in the presence of the women, and 75% in the presence of
the children, to psychologically control and coerce them. Mistreating
animals is a warning sign that others in the household may not be safe.The
Comission against Family and Gender Violence of the Primary Care Centers of
Sant Cugat and Valldoreix is developing a Multidisciplinary Program to
Attend Women victims of domestic violence and their companion animals
following the SAF-T guidelines. We have established collaboration with SPCAs
Fundaci�n Altarriba and Cau Amic to offer shelter for their companion
animals in case it is needed. For that purpose, we are asking screening key
questions in the emergency room or in the facility where the woman reports
violence. In a year-time, we have identified 30 women who lived animals, 76%
of them reported the animal being abused as well. In two cases, the abuser
chose the breed (german shepherd and bull terrier) and left the animal with
the woman when he left home. These dogs were poorly socialized and the women
felt unable to positive-train them, in a parallel way to what was happening
with their children which victimised the women in a way that was new for us.
In one case it was necessary to shelter 3 dogs because the woman emergency
shelter does not allow companion animals. For the 82% of the
children/youngsters the companion animals were a source of comfort and love.
3 cases in which they abused animals where identified: a 8-year old child
who is being abused by the father killed a companion fish and tried to kill
a canary. He also presents enuresis, fascination for fire, self-harm and
bullying. The two other are young women aged 19 and 21 diagnosed with
borderline personality disorder."
Both papers showed similar findings
to other studies that demonstrated a correlation between violence against
animals and later violence against humans. These results indicate that
animal abusers pose a threat to public safety and their behavior is
indicative of later crimes against humans.
Dr. N�ria Querol i Vi�as, MD, M.Sc, BSc.
Founder of GEVHA- Grupo
para el Estudio de la Violencia Hacia Humanos y Animales
American
Society of Criminology, Div. Critical Criminology
Sociedad Espa�ola
de Investigaciones Criminol�gicas
Comisi�n contra la Violencia
Familiar y de G�nero, Hospital Universitario M�tua Terrassa
Animals
and Society Institute, Scholar Member
http://www.gevha.com