By RANDOLPH E. SCHMID 03/ 7/11 03:00 PM
WASHINGTON -- Elephants quickly learn to lend each other a helping hand -- ah,
make that a helping trunk.
In a series of tests, the giant mammals learned to cooperate to solve a problem,
researchers report in Monday's edition of Proceedings of the National Academy of
Elephants are socially complex, explained lead researcher Joshua M. Plotnik.
"They help others in distress," he said. "They seem in some ways emotionally
attached to each other, so you would expect there would be some level of
However, he added, "I was surprised how quickly they learned."
The elephants caught on as quickly as chimpanzees, elevating themselves to such
heady company as great apes, dolphins and crows, according to Plotnik, of the
department of experimental psychology at England's Cambridge University.
The tests, conducted in Thailand, involved food rewards placed on a platform on
the ground connected to a rope. The elephants were behind a fence. To get the
food, the elephants had to pull the two ends of the rope at the same time to
drag the platform under the fence. Pull only one end and all you get is rope.
Six pairs of elephants were tested 40 times over two days and every pair figured
it out, succeeding on at least eight of the last 10 trials.
Then the scientists tried releasing the elephants into the test area separately,
up to 45 seconds apart. The elephants quickly learned to wait for their
partners, with a success rate of between 88 and 97 percent for various pairs on
the second day.
However, one young elephant had what the researchers termed an "unconventional"
solution to the problem. As Plotnik and co-authors explained, the elephant
firmly put one foot on the end of her rope, "forcing her partner to do all the
work to retrieve the table."
In another experiment, the researchers left only one end of the rope within
reach of the elephants, with the other end coiled on the table. The elephants
didn't bother to pull the rope, seeming to recognize that it wouldn't work if
their partner couldn't pull the other end.
It is hard to draw a line between learning and understanding, the researchers
concluded, but the elephants did engage in cooperative behavior and paid
attention to their partner.
Adam Stone, elephant program manager at Zoo Atlanta, said it was significant
that the elephants learned quickly.
"We're learning about the amazing mind of the elephant," he said.
It was long thought that learning and cooperation were limited to primates, and
"it's interesting to see that these other species are on the ball," Stone said.
Understanding how they think could help find ways to protect them in the wild,
he said, noting that the greatest danger to elephants in Asia is people.
Don Moore, associate director of animal care science at the Smithsonian's
National Zoo, said observations of elephants have suggested that they cooperate,
but it hadn't been experimentally tested before.
"Elephants are big, they're social, they live long lives and they're really,
really smart," he said.
Stone and Moore were not involved in the research, which was supported by the
U.S. Department of Education and other groups.