|
Page 2 ...
Look Within ...
Page 1
Page 3
Some thoughts to ponder. A
Concerned Rescuer in America
Yes, we are all guilty of not doing
enough and not embracing changes that could benefit the animals. Should
rescuers be doing more to bring forth humane education in their
communities?
Co-authored by Randy Warner and Mary Ultz, Humane
Educator City of Huntsville
To answer the question, I would say an
emphatic YES!! There is no other group of people who devote more time,
effort, compassion or personal finances into a job or hobby than do most
rescuers. But, educating just one family at a time, as opposed to 50
families at a time is obviously not as productive. And lets face it.
Trying to convince an adult to change their ways of handling and caring
for their pets is about as successful as convincing your spouse you are
‘right’ during an argument.
Rescuers are concerned with education,
they just don’t know it.
Should Rescuers be considered humane
educators as well?
They ARE! Sometimes they just don’t know it.
They speak from the front lines of the dog and cat rescue battles.
Rescuers have the most, as well as the best, information regarding pets
and their unique stories, along with the reasons why....
Rescue is
a passion-driven field. Logic and business sense are frequently put on
hold because some little angel needs some extra care today. I mean, it's
not like your profit margins are going to be factored by investors on
Monday, right?
Now, I'm quite sure that accomplishing an education
effort takes different strategies than what most of the public assumes,
but I believe it can be done. Not everyone will agree, not everyone will
wish to participate, but at the very least, nearly everyone can read this
and think about it.
From 1985 ‘til now I’ve done rescue primarily
for Dalmatians—and others when needed. I know how difficult it is, how
expensive it is, to what extent you can be drawn into an effort that never
seems to end.
It's the ''never seems to end'' part that I want to
ask YOU about. I'm addressing this to all those who devote their valuable
and wonderful time and assets toward saving dogs' lives, the rescuer. I
have a challenge for you…
I’d like to suggest that you give 20% of
your time, efforts and money to getting a strong and substantial humane
education program into your area schools. I do not mean to infer that your
present efforts are not necessary or important. I know it is crucial to so
many animals’ lives to continue what you’re doing.
But, that being
said, if you ONLY do rescue, you are simply making it easier for those who
are borderline about keeping their pets, and you are also assuring that
your children’s generation and your grandchildren’s generation will be
forced to do the same level of rescue as you do now. You must do
everything you can to educate this younger group of people before they
head down the very same path as their parents.
Each and every one
of you has the knowledge, experience, compassion and everything else
needed to make a HUGE difference in the next generation!!! You can't do it
by saying "I don't have time" or offering other excuses. Spending 100% of
your available time rescuing simply puts all future dogs in jeopardy,
because you did NOT do enough to resolve the underlying problems for the
future. You will continue to clean up the mess after yesterday’s parade. I
would hope that you would rather see the front of the horse once in a
while.
If you are willing to work toward this momentous effort, I
don’t want you to be overwhelmed. Try 5% per year for humane education
over the next five years and increase accordingly. Some of you are not
comfortable as public speakers. If that is the case, consider recruiting a
friend or neighbor who supports your efforts and wants to do more. Many
schools (even in this economy) have ''speaker'' funds and will write you a
check for $100 as you leave. You could bring in as much as $500/week for 5
hours’ work. We all know how helpful money is in our pocket. Why not earn
money for our rescue endeavors while we spread the message to make rescue
unnecessary? As a rescuer, you can send information to schools of your
choice and follow up to see which class got that information.
What
if you spent only one hour a weekend handing out information to the
public? Minimal cost for copies, countless contacts to pet
owners!
If you have a website, place some information there as
well. One more link about the overpopulation and how people can help end
it will not take too much effort, but will save lives in the end!
Everything I have on my site is for public use. The more people that check
out my site, the more their awareness and information levels increase,
thus they act more responsibly. If you don’t have the time for another
page, PUT A LINK TO MY PAGE ON YOUR PAGE! Everything on my site will
resound loudly in the ears of anyone who has helped with rescue and
listening to the idiots make up excuses for these poor innocent
pets.
Some principals tell me that I’m not needed at their school,
because most of their students already have pets. WELL, A BIG STUPID DUH
TO THEM!! But once I’m invited into a school, you would not believe the
impact that my 45-minute program has on these young minds. I take all five
of my dogs: 2 dals, (one deaf) a coyote, a pit bull and a beagle-basset
mix. My presentation is blunt, direct, fun, AND VERY INFORMATIVE. I barely
mention what they think they'll hear. When we depart, each face looks so
much different from when we first arrived. It’s amazing. The kids are
motivated to form a humane education club or at least take on a year long
project to accomplish something to help animals. Amazingly, teachers and
staff tell me how much even they learned and then thank me.
You
need to be well versed in supportive information to check all claims,
suggestions and rules enforced in contracts. I'll bet every rescuer out
there knows exactly what I'm talking about.
I just hope that some
of you see that we all have room for growth, change and expansion of our
duties. If we are creative, we can accomplish so much more. If only 20% of
the rescuers who read this decide to do SOMETHING, that would be over a
thousand people. Now, a thousand people visiting schools just 3 times a
year is 3,000 MORE classrooms visited. 3,000 classrooms this year with 40
students each is 120,000 EDUCATED youth who will not likely need to
services of rescuers or animal control agencies except for adoptions.
Then, I've surpassed my goal considerably!! For all those who say 'we
can't' for whatever reason, would you rather be part of the Rescue
Janitorial staff than the Engineering or Research Departments who will
be a vital part of the solution?
When you pass on, can you
guarantee that someone similar will step into your shoes and take over
with the same fervor and compassion to save the dogs of tomorrow??
Wouldn't you like to try and save some of them NOW while you can? With
every good presentation you give, you are likely to save 10-50 dogs
depending on the number of ears listening. And it only takes an hour and
maybe $15. (gas, 50 copies and lunch at McDonalds on the way
home)
CAN YOU MEET THE CHALLENGE OF EDUCATION TO CREATE PROBLEM
RESOLUTION?
I would love nothing more than NOT to do rescue because
it is not necessary. Until then, I will continue along my path of
education for solution. I choose to be pro-active to end overpopulation,
not just re-active to current demands.
“I am only one, but
still I am one. I cannot do everything, but still I can do something; and
because I cannot do everything, I will not refuse to do something that I
can do.”
I would suggest to those who continue with rescue, to
WORK SMART, NOT HARD
An article on 'Backyard Breeders' that I wrote
in 1999 for a local paper which had begun stressing overpopulation and was
receiving much scrutiny and anger from the locals:
AMERICANS WILL
KILL UPWARDS OF 8 MILLION HEALTHY, ADOPTABLE PETS THIS YEAR. WHY? TOO
MANY PETS – NOT ENOUGH HOMES! WHO IS AT FAULT? ANYONE AND EVERYONE WHO
HAS A LITTER FOR FUN, FOR PROFIT, OR “BY ACCIDENT’’! THE ‘’BACKYARD
BREEDER’’ Backyard Breeders misrepresent themselves as
responsible/respectable breeders. They have the misguided thoughts that
AKC papers means their pet is breeding quality. If you allow your pet to
parent even one litter, then YOU are the solutions’ BIGGEST problem!
Unless you honestly don't know how dogs become pregnant or are just
retarded, there is no such thing as an accidental litter.
|
Most Americans tend to
view the problems of animal abuse and pet overpopulation from the
same vantage point. We certainly hope you don't see yourself
in this photo. |

|
I foster, rehabilitate and
place rescued dogs of many breeds. Dalmatians are one of my specialty
breeds but I also rescue, train and foster many others as well. Because of
this, I WANT to speak out today on the issue of breeding for fun and
profit. Some of you will be upset by this written piece and that is good,
maybe you'll help us do something about the problem. For, each person who
throws their arms in the air, or rolls their eyes in disgust for something
I’ve said in this piece, you are the likely intended target. For
verification on anything I say on this page, ask ANY person associated
with an animal welfare group or facility – ANYWHERE. BACKYARD BREEDERS
ARE -
**Anyone who has a litter for fun, profit or by
‘accident’. **Anyone who is so uninformed that they think having AKC
papers means that their pet is breeding quality. **Anyone who
advertises their litters in the local paper for sale. (respected breeders
only advertise in trade magazines) **Anyone who thinks that by finding
their puppies good homes that they somehow don’t have to play by the rules
or take responsibility. **Anyone who thinks they found their litter
good homes, simply because everyone that took one, smiled honestly and
‘promised’ to treat them well.. Thus insisting on no background check, no
enforceable contract or any type of follow up. **They will provide
erroneous information to the potential adopters regarding the required
care and treatment necessary for the pet - simply for their own personal
gains Respectable breeders will have walls adorned with trophies and
certificates which represent the numerous championships they’ve acquired
over the years.
If you take personal offense to it then you need
to examine your activities very carefully as you are likely my target or
reason for writing this. If you wish to respond negatively to this, you
will find you won't get much support from myself or those who are
knowledgeable. I am speaking OUT today, not only for myself, but also for
all rescuers across the nation, all of the ‘respectable’ breeders around
the country and all of the responsible pet guardians. Therefore, I will
not say, "In my humble opinion", as this opinion is shared by the
respected breeders and pet guardians, as well as the ASPCA, Humane Society
of the United States and all of the Shelters and other Humane/Animal
Welfare organizations in this country.
Up to 8 million healthy
animals are killed in U.S. pounds and shelters every year. The majority of
killing could easily be prevented by spaying OR neutering. Euthanasia is
the single largest cause of death for dogs in the U.S. Each year 27
million DOGS are born. 8 or more million we classify as "surplus" ARE
killed. That's about ¾ million per month. These numbers do not include the
millions of dead dogs whose bodies we scrape off the streets, the growing
number that are put to sleep at vets’ offices or the hundreds of thousands
THAT ARE abandoned.
LET'S NOT FORGET THE severely neglected or
abused ones who never make it to our shelters to be counted and OR
EUTHANIZED. The ten million figure represents those we "MUST" kill because
they are unwanted!!! Most of these animals are young and healthy; in fact,
it is estimated that a majority are less than one year of age. The problem
is simple: we have too many dogs...Too many for the too few homes
available TO THEM. The solution we have opted for is to kill the extras.
This solution has been considered acceptable by default, as though there
were no other way to control the crisis. And we spend over $11 billion
every year destroying "man's best friend."
A common sense look that
you cannot deny or argue with: If you were part of a company who made
‘pets’ and every year for the past 20 years, you had been overstocked to
the point of having to dispose of the overstocked inventory, what would
you suggest they do this year to improve? So, if you KNOW we are killing
this vast number of innocent, loving animals each year, why in the world
would you think that having a litter of puppies or kittens is
OK?
Why is this happening in the United States today? The number
one biggest contributor to the problem is the "backyard breeder" not the
puppy mills. This is a name that has become unpopular and no one wants to
admit they are a "backyard breeder". Anyone having a litter in their home
with just the family pet as one of the breeding parents, and advertise in
the local papers) Many people do not even realize they are part of the
problem. This is what I need to address in this post. The only way to stop
the needless killing of dogs is to stop the needless breeding of
them.
Every breed of dog
recognized by the AKC has a written standard, a blueprint of what the dog
should look like and act like. These standards were written so that all
would know what a quality example of the breed is and strive to produce
dogs that meet or exceed the standard in health, temperament and
appearance. To be sure you are breeding dogs that meet these standards,
your dogs must be judged by people who have a lifetime of experience among
the breed. If your personal dog has not yet been in front of a judge, then
you do NOT have an AKC standard dog, you have one that is pet quality and
that is fine. AKC papers DO NOT signify a dog with Breeding quality
standards!!!!!
. A pet is to be loved,
cherished, trained, cared for, spoiled and bragged about, but it is NEVER
to be bred. No matter how cute or sweet the dog may be, if it is not up to
the standard, you have no business breeding it. Even if you have a
purebred dog this does not give you the right to breed it. Most purebred
dogs are not breeding quality. If you breed your pet quality dog, you are
a "backyard breeder", whether you breed the dog in your backyard, garage,
living room or an expensive hotel room, the term is still backyard
breeder. If your pet quality dog has AKC papers, that's nice but it
doesn't change anything. You still don't have the right to breed it. If
your pet quality dog cost you $500 be glad you had the money to afford it.
You still have no right to breed it.
Do you think you can RECOUP
your $500 INVESTMENT if you breed your pet dog? OR DO YOU THINK YOUR pet
dog is a color or size that isn't in the standard but you just know
everyone will want buy a pup if you breed her? Shame on you! Now you are a
"backyard breeder" with the purpose of breeding pups for fun and profit.
That is despicable!!!
If the price for a tail dock or an ear crop
seems high to you, what are you going to do when your beloved pet needs an
emergency C-section? Will you even be there to know if she is in trouble?
Would you recognize trouble before its too late AND BE MONETARILY ABLE TO
SEEK VETERINARY HELP?
If you still want to
breed your pet but need to ask, "Who's suppose to cut off the tails and
ears"? Ask yourself, "What the Hell am I thinking?" Do you think genetic
testing is something they used in the OJ trial but has nothing to do with
your dog-breeding career you are a "backyard breeder".
"Backyard
breeders" sell pups that aren't up to the standard of the breed. They do
this for many reasons. None are good enough reasons to contribute to the
killing of dogs. Period.
"Backyard breeders" will swear all of
their pups went to a good home. They believe this, but it's not
NECESSARILY true. Some may have been lucky enough to go to a good home at
the time of adoption, but more than half of them will end up dead, in a
shelter alone, on a cold table with a needle sticking out of their leg.
Why? Because the Backyard Breeder didn’t follow through or even know
enough about adoptions to ask the right questions up front. Some of those
good homes will get tired of the dog and they will just give it away to
anyone who is willing to take it. Some of your beloved dog's children will
end up living alone in a backyard, barking all night, cold and neglected
until the guardian gets complaints and then that pups will be dead. Some
will be starved and beaten. Some will be bred until they die from THE MANY
BIRTHS.
Some will end up in
rescue and I will have to find space for it in my home. I will GIVE IT
LOVE TO SHOW IT that not all humans are bad. I will train it, and feed it
the proper food so it can heal, MENTALLY AS WELL AS PHYSICALLY. I will
take the fleas off and I will get rid of the worms. I will give it the
shots it should have had but no one remember to DO it. I will do these
things because the "backyard breeder" didn't. I will spay or neuter that
pup before I find it a new home so that I will never have to rescue one of
it's pups. THAT WAY I CAN BE ASSURED it will never end up in the hands of
another "backyard breeder" looking to make profit from
puppies.
"Backyard breeders" are not responsible pet guardians.
They claim that they love the dogs but it's not true because they don't
really want to be bothered with doing all that it takes to breed
ethically. They love feeling important when they say, "I breed mini
schnauzers". But breeding pet dogs isn't something to be proud of. IT'S a
shame on our society. It's the reason for the killing that goes on in
shelters. Why do you want to be part of that? Do you want to be respected?
Spay or neuter you pet dog. There's really no other way. The kind of homes
you want for your pet pups don't want to buy from you. They are looking
for responsible, respected breeders who are doing something for the breed
as a whole. Most of those WHO WILL BUY your pups are the kind of people I
wouldn't give a dog I didn't like to. They are the ones who will turn your
puppy into a shelter when the novelty wears off. That's a PROVEN fact.
Want to stop the problem of killing 1 Million dogs a month all over
America? Spay or neuter your pet dog now and tell everyone you know to do
the same. Leave the breeding to the people who are doing something to
better the breed.
DO you want to have a litter of puppies to show
your children the miracle of life? Then to be fair and honest, volunteer
yourself and your children to work at the county dog pound for no less
than three days to show them the miracle of death. After all, as a
'backyard breeder' you are now the single most contributing factor to the
pet overpopulation problems that we all face and which cause the millions
of healthy pets to be killed each year in this nation.
The failures of
the lawmakers, the laws, the courts and local
governments
Jail Time:
Yes I spent time in jail
trying to make my point and rightfully so. Most of the time I seemed to
have problems staying out of trouble with the top level animal control
officials. At the same time, when the field officers would come to my
home, at the direction of their superiors, they not only sympathized with
what I was doing, she also very supportive of my efforts and did what they
could to keep me out of trouble.
A knock on the door by the
officer only to see my home and yard busy with activity from the number of
Dalmatians in my care. Happy, healthy and bothering nobody. Seeing as
though the limit was 3, I usually had 8-10 in the earlier years. The
officer would say with a wink, "I only see three Dalmatians today, don't
I?' and then step inside with a pint of Cherry Vanilla Ice Cream and ask
me to get two spoons.
In one community they would pay the animal
control officer overtime to sit and wait for me to come home in the
evening so he could actually write me a ticket for having too many animals
with me. One time, I was walking them all to the store and Maddy was off
leash and he gave me a ticket for dog at large. That was the first time I
went to jail, but was released as soon as they had my finger prints and
mug shot.
One time I was taken to jail was when Orange County
was tired of giving warnings of my having too many dogs in my one bedroom
condo at the beach. Sometimes as many as seven. But we would go on a
morning walk, spend a solid three hours each day at a different doggy park
and then go to the beach at sunset. They were not 'wanting' anything. AND
NO NEIGHBORS HAD COMPLAINED EITHER.
My limit was ten dogs. Never
any more. And on the same day, the orange county pound called and said
they had two Dalmatians for me =- would I take them? I said yes. That
would bring my number of dogs to 9. Funny, how I arrived home to find two
Dalmatians tied up to my front door with a small note saying they MUST go
to me or be killed. Well, now I'm already over the limit that the county
has placed on me. but who's going to find out this soon?????
Within
two or three hours of my returning, the sheriff was there and brought
along 2 animal control trucks to remove the animals.
I was forced
to sit on my living room floor in handcuffs as the neighbors outside were
screaming at the authorities to stop this nonsense because all I was doing
was trying to help save lives. They finally had each and every dog loaded
into the two trucks and proceeded to put me in the back of the sheriff's
car.
Instead of being released on
OR as usual, they actually made me stay there until I saw the judge. They
decided to play hardball. They made me see a judge up in Santa Ana who had
no idea of who I was or what I'd been doing over the years. and saw how
many citations I had been issued. He decided to throw me in jail for 30
days. Now mind you, I only stayed for 9, but I learned more about myself
in those nine days that I had in the previous 42 years.
I made
the call to get a ride back home so I could see my two baby girls that I
loved so dearly. The other 9 dogs had all been killed immediately upon
arrival at the shelter 9 days earlier. never had a chance. It had been a
set up by the county animal control to catch me and so they would know
exactly when I would in fact have more than they had set the limits at.
I moved out of Orange County soon afterwards. I was now making my
living from training dogs and doing some boarding over holiday periods
when other kennels were full.
Now, I'm moving away from the beach
which is highly populated and crowded to beautiful and very rural interior
of Riverside County. Filled with rednecks in office. I'm thinking that
some acreage in the country would be much more appropriate for my efforts.
Everyone was hoping for a much calmer and more supportive lifestyle for my
efforts.
|
I found my first place
in the Ortega Mountains in a cool 2 bedroom A frame at the entrance
of a state park and campground. What a dream location for this. It
wasn't more than 3 months after moving in that the Press Enterprise
asked to do a story on my efforts and placed the color photo and
feature on the front page. |

|
The following day, I was
visited by animal control to give me a citation. When I refused to sign
it, they radioed for a sheriff to come and calm the
situation.
But, this is only the
beginning of an unbelievable ride - one that would shed much light on the
greed and ignorance within the animal control system around our nation and
stems directly from the stupidity of many supervisory boards from given
and various counties. For the next three + years, I was being taken to
court a total of 43 times. Each time was a different case, but all were
exactly the same charge. An infraction with a max fine of $100 for not
having a proper kennel license. Gaining unbelievable amounts of
information from a variety of attorneys who offered to help pro bono, I
was able to extend this case for the duration, only to be ultimately found
not guilty. At a total cost to taxpayers of $60,000+
It was more
than apparent that had the animal control been doing their job, there
would be much less of a need for met to do what I was doing. For me to get
a license, was acceptable at $260/yr. But to charge me nearly $10,000 in
various fees just to get that license was what I was clearly protesting
since I didn't have the money and not one red cent of that was to protect
or ensure the animals safety or well being - it was just a 'law' that had
too much government involvement.
Keep in mind throughout the
entire Riverside County fiasco, the ONLY thing that anyone was trying to
rule on, was 'did Randy Warner have the proper license' and it was clear I
did not have that, but they kept finding me not guilty or dismissing the
case due to extenuating circumstances and clearly supported by the courts
and especially the public and the media.
During this period of
time, I would appear in front of more than 35 judges for the exact same
violation over and over again. When one judge would sympathies with my
efforts and dismiss the case, the county would become more angered and
outspoken. So the next judge, who would also be in a different part of the
county at a different courthouse, was likely going to dismiss the charges
as well.
If not he/she would fine me and I'd then be forced
to appeal the decision which ultimately lead to my being heard by yet
another court which usually resulted in my being found not guilty each
time. Usually within days, the brainiacs at Riverside County Animal
Control then would send a field officer to issue yet another citation for
the same.
Here was the problem. In order to be granted this
license, I had to have kennels constructed for the dogs that met their
strict requirements. First of all, the dogs in my care were and are
allowed to run freely within the confines of my securely fenced 1.75
acres. They learn to share the food from one single large feeder and drink
from a large water bowl without fighting. They have unlimited play time,
sleep under the oak tree or on my bed. This provides them with the future
expectations once they find their 'forever' homes. I didn't want to build
kennels.
I was also not in a position of spending the $3,500 it
would take to build them.
Also, my landlords would not have
permitted me to do so as they didn't want to have their rental property
resembling a dog pound for future renters, but fully supported my efforts
as they were.
To complicate this matter even further, the county
would NOT allow me to build the kennels until the planning and zoning
department did a study/survey on the land and would require a temporary
use permit which would cost $6,000 also.
The worst of the whole
deal was that they fully expected, based on my numbers of dogs I usually
cared for, that they would also require me to build handicapped parking
and a handicapped bathroom as they would consider me to be operating as a
business.
Other requirements were that I build a separate food
preparation facility, which I could only assume was to be used for special
occasions when I fed my dogs caviar and roasted duck.
To construct
a separate septic system with underground tank for the animals' waste.
Heaven forbid, their poop would ever be mixed with my poop.
On
my second appearance in the Perris courthouse, Judge Loree presided. As I
approached the bench, (with the Press Enterprise and LA Times in the
courtroom) the judge said, “I sure hope that you are not the famous
Dalmatian man that I( keep reading about in all the papers. is that you?
When I replied with the affirmative, she looked upset. Then she announced
that she and her husband had just discussed this over dinner the night
before.
|
She said 'clearly with
my job in these courts, I feel you should be made a hero and not a
criminal and could not be fair in this case. The county will now be
forced to secure another venue for this trial if they choose to
continue/ And Mr. Warner, I respect your efforts. Thanks for what
you do. |

|
The
above photo of my home is an illegal act in Riverside County,
CA.
I was just stunned. I didn't know what had just
happened. She said, 'You may go now' and I turned away to walk out. As I
exited the courtroom, the bailiff stopped me and gave me a five dollar
bill to help out with the dog food and I broke out in tears. The media
just ate this up.
This was not the first time that a judge had
respected my efforts and sympathized with what I was forced to do in order
to be the law abiding rescue effort with that given county. Four years
earlier in Orange County and appearing in court to answer to charges that
were obviously trumped up just to make me look worse, the judge quickly
recognized it and also dismissed the charges against me following some
very stern words to animal control and a supportive nod in my
direction.
Also, during the midst of this 40 month battle, the new
Heydn Bill was introduced and passed through the CA legislature. This new
law would force county and city funded animal facilities to make every
attempt to work with their local breed rescues to find more homes for the
animals in lieu of almost certain death. The animals would be required to
be vaccinated and spayed and neutered prior to our acceptance of the
animals - all at no charge to the rescuers.
So, now the county was
under pressure to abide by the law and allow me to adopt any Dalmatian
within their care. They, of course refused to do so and I made that very
clear in court as well.
Throughout this 3 and 1/2 year battle of
the wits and laws, the laws were so poorly written that even one judge
dismissed the case because he knew nothing of it and the officer from the
county couldn't provide any information. Now they have been made to look
stupid in the media again and are getting angry. Two days later in an
article in the Press Enterprise, the board of supervisors announced that
they would be reviewing the judges decision and he would be placed on
administrative leave for two days pending their decision.
The next
time I was taken to court I was told that the case would not continue
until I had posted a bail f $243. not a huge bale amount, but I don't have
that kind of money - it all goes for dog food. And who in the world thinks
I'm a flight risk? It became clear that the judge had received
instructions from the county supervisors. Now, keep in mind, this follows
the other judge who knew nothing of the particular law and dismissed my
case. This was their way to even the score. It was at this time that the
Los Angeles Times deemed them the 'hillbilly mafia''.
So, I was now
forced to file a request for the courts to postpone my trial as I needed
to raise the bail amount. Of course that also was covered in several
newspapers and the funds came quickly.
The one that brought me
to tears was from Nancy and Zubin Mehta. Zubin is the conductor of the LA
Philharmonic Orchestra and had asked his audience of that previous Friday
night to pass the hat in an effort to help the man in Riverside County
fighting for the lives of so many innocent animals. They sent a check for
$2,450.
The judge hearing this particular case was expecting to
preside over a routine case of someone with too many dogs. After hearing
my defense, he also decided to dismiss the case due to the fact he found
no justifiable actions to curb my efforts as there had never been any
complaints and recognized the passion and defensive arguments for my
efforts. By the time the court session was over, with a continuance, no
action taken and several area media reporters present as well, he
commented to one of the court employees '”I'd love to know the details of
this case.' Then he remembered that he had barred several Los Angeles
based TV crews from entering his court room, but now wondered if there
could be any connection. He asked to speak to one of them still outside
and figured out who I was.
On a given afternoon in my mail, I see a
citation from Orange County. why, I've not been to Orange county is over a
year. It was a notice to appear due to the fact that I had violated my
probation by breaking the law in Riverside County.
Number one:
Nobody follows through with a violation of an infraction. Number two:
I'd yet to be found guilty on any one of them.
Luckily for me,
upon arrival at Orange county courts, I was fortunate enough to see Judge
Pamela Aisles, who had been supportive of me into he past. She agreed that
this was odd, couldn't understand how it came to the attention of the
courts and promptly changed the probation from ''break no laws'' to
''abuse nor neglect any animals in your care''. Then she handed me the
updated copy with a smile and wished me luck.
Since that little
tactic failed, I now find myself pulled over on the highway as I go to the
grocery one day. I was placed in handcuffs and told by the officers that
they really think this is an unfortunate argument between the county and
myself as they quickly recognized me from all the coverage, but were
instructed to bring me to jail for violation of a county ordinance that
prohibits operation of a pig ranch within the city limits of an
incorporated community.
I have no pigs. I live nine miles outside
the city limits on 1.75 acres. when arriving at the jail, the officer
there, didn't quite know what to do. But he made sure my stay was as short
as possible and got me out quickly. The media decided not to run this
story and were beginning to side with me as was most of the public in the
Los Angeles Basin of communities. This was just another attempt of the
Riverside County Board of Supervisors to levy fines and fees as well as
charges of abusing the law in order to garner more support for finally
receiving a guilty verdict against me in the future.
Then, out of
the clear blue sky, there was an article in the newspaper where the
supervisors had approved stiffer penalties for those who keep more than
Riverside County Law provides. Those who reviewed the new set of laws
agreed they were much stricter, but argued that they were even less
understandable than the original set. The laws never went into
effect.
Soon after that, in another failed attempt to justify their
anger with my ongoing battle with them, they claimed that this would have
to be resolved very soon as they just didn't have the funds to continue.
In the same article, the reporter mentioned that the county had just
recently reduced the budget for this growing county from 3% to just
1.5%.
Not surprising to anyone, was the fact that during the very
same month, the county supervisors had just voted themselves an annual pay
increase of 35%. Hmmm, I wonder where those funds came from?
I then
felt it necessary to question why the county is so eager to place so many
financial obstacles in he paths of those who only rescue existing animals
but have no program nor restrictions for those who breed for profit or
allow for recreational litters. It doesn't make sense to me that they will
allow any idiot to have litters, tie them upside down in the attic if they
wish, paint them all purple, nor provide them with any vaccinations what
so ever, but for those who try to assist in the ever growing problems of
pet overpopulation, they require this, that and everything else in the
world to attempt and prevent us from doing so.
The final
battle
After one judge required me to post a bail of $243 (as if
some idiot expected me to be a flight risk,) I was then forced to ask for
a postponement of my next hearing so I could raise the funds.
Since he set the following court date in a futile and final
attempt to ultimately resolve this issue between the county and myself, he
did in fact hear the final two days of testimony and trial. I would say
this judge was undoubtedly the most stern of all the judges I'd had
throughout this bitch fest, but saw his gasp when he looked at the photos
and was quiet for a few moments. Then when he waived the fine so I could
use it on my ''drug of choice'' (dog food for my rescues) I knew this
would be a victory when it all came out in the wash.
It was that
evening when Jean Schmidt of Imperial County called me at home. She had
been following the trials for over three years and happened to be a huge
dog lover. Then she said 'oh, by the way, did I tell you that I'm also
offering my services to make sure you are victorious in your battle. I'm a
retired California Supreme Court Justice.” My mouth just dropped open and
didn't really know what to say.
She was a gruff and very short
speaking type person. This was a cause that she supported wholeheartedly,
but wasn't too pleased with my questioning her suggestions. She frequently
hung up on me in disgust, but would always make her way to come to the
phone the next time I called. Over the next few weeks she made me do some
things that were rather on the odd side, but I did them and they all had a
strong impact that helped with the case - none of which would I have ever
thought of in a million years.
One: Place an ad in the Press
Enterprise that is 2” X 2” and has a border to make it visible. In the ad,
you ask for any local or area gays and other minorities from the county
who have experienced prejudicial treatment based on that fact and to call
this special number that she had me set up. within 4 days, I had received
over 70 calls from people all over the county who knew who I was and felt
they too were discriminated against. I took their phone numbers and names
but did little else, According to Jean, the damage had already been done.
Just let them think that you are coming to court with all your guns and
they will be loaded to the hilt.
The next thing she made me do was
to get a large 4ft square sign made out of poster board. Glue the photos
of the Board of supervisors and the animal control supervisor to the
poster. Each photo should be no smaller than 8'' X 8” so that they would
be recognizable in a public area. he text should be this and nothing else:
WHEN IS THE LAST TIME YOUR ELECTED OFFICIALS HAVE BEEN PROPERLY CHARGED
AND FINED WITH THEIR CRIMES OF SPOUSAL BATTERY, CHILD MOLESTATION OR
ANIMAL ABUSE?
She explained to me that with the question, I would
likely be handcuffed and taken in, but that they would quickly realize
that you can ask any question you wish. What this did was to place doubt
and questions in the minds of the county residents, because it was so
drastic, that the media was there in about 20 min and 2 min later, the
cops had me in cuffs. Following day it was on the front page of the Press
Enterprise along with one of their 18 feature articles about my battle to
save the poor Dalmatians. Funny thing is, some of those who read the sign,
actually went to work checking up on the history of all those mentioned
and found 2 domestic violence charges and one had a pending charge for
inappropriate behavior with a minor. So it also had some very strong
impacts on the trial outcome. Now, they just didn't know what to expect
from this crazy man who loves his dogs. On two occasions, throughout this
3 + year battle, I personally and professionally addressed the Riverside
County Board of supervisors and brought others who would also speak on my
behalf.
|

|
Our goal was to
obtain a variance to allow me to obtain the license without
constructing the kennels, the separate septic system, separate food
preparation area and the handicapped parking and handicapped
bathroom. |
I explained how I was
physically not permitted to construct the required kennels, nor was it
even in my financial options either. I reviewed the benefits of the free
reign socializing tactics I used and could prove that it did not make them
out of control as they had accused me of. ''These dogs are allowed to run
free without being kenneled and have developed a pack mentality'' . Then
they go into a home with children? That would be very dangerous!!'' they
said.
Well duh. They are in a
'group' right now. There is no clear and strong leader. They do not 'stand
together' for any survival needs. As long as they are in my care, they
have no enemies. We have no fights. Occasional misunderstandings or tiffs
will occur, but are immediately squelched by me. I'd like to see you put
30 kids on a playground and expect to see no disagreements, minor injuries
and a few tears from a mishap. You aren't suggesting that the schools
contain them in secure cages.
What I found interesting
in all of this is the failure to recognize that I have NEVER had
complaints about the temperament of any of my rescued dogs, nor of
mistreatment of neglect in all my years of rescue. And not one of the
supervisors had ever come to see for themselves nor even sent a
representative. When I reminded them of what the animal control officer
put on his initial report, they denied ever seeing that. Hmmmm (''On May
4th, 1996, I visited the resident of Randy Warner on Ortega Highway where
he has a small rescue efforts for Dalmatians. the animals were happy,
seemed healthy and well fed. The premises was clean, securely fenced and
were very responsive to Warner's commands and affection")
By the way, when they
find their 'forever' homes, they are usually the only dog in the home,
although sometimes there is another. So, how would they 'carry on' with
their pack mentality and do harm to humans.?
Anyway, each time I
tried to explain that this is only a humane effort on my part and have
much success that I can point to, will gladly offer as many happy new
adoptees as they wish to have and am only asking for a variance. The
variance would allow me to continue without being prosecuted constantly,
would provide for unannounced visits by animal control to determine the
animals safety and well being and this would alleviate the requirement
issues that are preventing me from actually obtaining the license that
this entire battle is about.
Both times I formally
spoke to them with this request, they said they had no reason to do so.
Funny how they had enough of a reason to battle with me for 4 years and
spend nearly $65,000 to bring me to court 43 times - only to see the end
result of my receiving a 'not guilty ' verdict from the courts. Not to
mention the public slamming them pretty hard and ultimately treating me as
if I were a local folk hero.
It was also that previous hearing
with Riverside County Imbeciles, I believe it was my 41st appearance - the
judge that heard me this particular time wanted to be stern and settle the
matter. As I was about to leave, he gave me a mandate that I place at
least 10 of the 25 that I had at that appearance and not accept any new
ones until all was ok with the county. I agreed.
Next court date
was one month. On the third week, I had done very well to stay within his
mandate by placing 9 of the ten he wanted to see placed. However, three
days before the court appearance, I received a call from Christine at the
Downey Dog Pound. They had been inundated with Dalmatians and there were
15 of them that were going to be euthanized that evening and asked if I
could help. I told her I'd gladly accept them if someone would provide
transportation and all shots had been administered. She
agreed.
That evening a van pulled into my place which was a two
hour drive from the Downey facility and I could see clearly that the van
was full, but especially noticed three of the most angelic faces peering
out the rear window anyone could imagine. I ran and grabbed my camera and
snapped the shot for court.
We unloaded all of them shortly and the
worker was on his way. Now I had to go to court and explain to him that my
efforts are clearly those that people obviously cannot find within their
own counties - Riverside Included. With the recent release of the Disney
Live Action Movie, those who rescued Dalmatians have never been busier and
that there was no law nor effort through the county's laws that could
justify allowing these faces to die just because the county is requiring
that I do things like they do. OBVIOUSLY it was the law, but Obviously it
wasn't working. If it weren't' for 322 rescues across Riverside county,
just imagine how many dogs and cats would have died needlessly and these
little angels are a prime example.
Also, throughout the trial,
since each hearing was attended by a different representative from the
animal control office and none of them appeared to be able to add 2 + 2, I
kept the heat on. I'd ask in front of the judge, 'What college did you
graduate from?" and they would appear as a deer in the headlight, the
judge would ask, 'To what benefit is that for anyone to know?"
My response was quickly,
'you'll see within the next 15 minutes." Then I would begin bringing out
the documents showing how they as an agency had failed on this, come up
short on this, been investigated recently by these organizations and state
entities and the charges that had been levied against them over the
years.
The Final Trial
Throughout the daylong trial, Pamela
Anderson, the county attorney ( is much more resembling Roseanne Barr than
the Pamela Anderson most of you are thinking of) and the idiot who was in
charge of animal control who had been under severe scrutiny for many many
years and never made any attempts to correct the problems that upset so
many. Sick animals, loosing animals belonging to residents, euthanizing
too soon, never being open when the public could possibly pay them a visit
to handle business or consider adopting one of their animals.
On more than one occasion,
they, with their 'sad eyes' and hearts full of compassion suggested to me
as they addressed the courts, that I simply should make the decision to
turn all my animals over to them as they were more appropriately set up
and trained to handle numbers of animals than I.
Without missing a
beat, I interrupted their little sickening acting job and said' Now, wait
a minute here. Aren't' you the people who run Riverside county animal
shelter? You still kill your dogs after just three days don't you. By the
way, when is the last time you walked through your facility to kiss each
dog goodnight as I do and call each one by name?
Both turned red
and the supervisor demanded that the court consider me a hostile witness.
The judge said YOU CAN'T CALL MR. WARNER A HOSTILE WITNESS. HE'S
AUTOMATICALLY A HOSTILE WITNESS. YOU ARE PROSECUTING HIM. and gave him a
dirty look. He put his head down and just barely made eye contact with me
as the judge was preparing for the next phase of the hearing.
I
whispered loudly across the front of the courtroom to the animal control
supervisor 'HEY, TOM. IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR YOUR TESTICLES, I BELIEVE THE
JUDGE KICKED THEM UNDER THAT FILING CABINET OVER THERE and gave a huge
smile to show that I had no hard feelings. The judge heard my comments and
instructed that everyone must remain quiet until and unless addressed by
himself. When he looked down, he had a smirk on his face as I'm sure he
was chuckling inside.
It was then that I presented my stacks of
information showing that they charge more to the tax payers for killing
the animals than they do for adopting - thus the reason they aren't open
convenient hours, don't' want to see my efforts or those of the remaining
rescues to be successful as it truly is a financial means of increasing
all their year end profits
His only comment was 'Mr. Warner, it is
clear you have a big heart and are using it to do very good deeds. What
the county and the courts are trying to get you to do is to find a way in
which you can continue these noble efforts without breaking the laws. So,
I'm going to set a final trial one month from today.
I expect BOTH parties to
come prepared with attorneys, homework done and have a solution that we
can all live with. Mr. Warner, I'm going to fine you $45 today for not
coming to court with a number that showed a reduction of at least ten dogs
as was required on your previous appearance. However, I'm going to waive
that fine as it seems to me you will need it for dog food.
Of
course, they soon found out. I spent every waking hour on the phone with
one of three attorneys who all offered to represent me in court. I told
them all no. I just wanted to win all by myself. So, they explained what
the procedure is and how I should respond. What I should take along to
present to the courts and even how and when to try and object to the
prosecutions' idiocy'. I must have taken some good notes from everyone.
This trial was tentatively scheduled for the morning session at 10 am and
should be 20-30 minutes long. This is my day and I will not allow it to be
taken from me.
When we broke for lunch I
was ecstatic. I'd kept it going for 2 full hours at least. The afternoon
was also productive. the judge did not take kindly to the prosecution's
slanderous remarks about my lack of preparedness for these procedures.
Came back even more motivated than in the morning. Especially when I
noticed that Pamela Anderson, the county attorney had dressed up like a
Dalmatian as the prosecution atty. she thought since it was getting so
much media coverage that it would be humorous.
On the second day of
this very public trial and certainly against everyone 's better judgment,
I did what I had to do. The morning of the trial, I wore a cheap Halloween
wig, put a pillow under a blouse I'd thrown on along with a borrowed
skirt. Then I painted my lips way over the lip's edge in bright gaudy red
and went to court. The Bailiffs questioned me and almost refused to allow
me to enter. They finally did and made me sit in the far back corner of
the court until the judge called the case..
''The county of
Riverside vs. Randy Warner'' will the parties please step forward.
INSTANTLY I hear the judge interrupt and ask Mr. Warner, now I understand
this is a passion of yours, but will you please explain your wardrobe this
morning?
Yes sir, I'd be happy to. Yesterday Pamela Anderson (no
secret I hated her as much as she hated me.) was kind enough to dress like
a Dalmatian rescuer. In a sarcastic tone of voice, I'd continue, I assumed
it was to comfort me in this difficult battle so I decided to repay the
favor and have simply come to court today dressed like Pamela Anderson.
The judge blew out some air in an attempt not to laugh, but it was
clear as to his understanding of my humor and willingness to pull out all
the guns necessary to throw them off guard in hopes of
winning.
''We will proceed. Mr. Warner, I will require you to
remove the wig. I would demand that you remove the women's clothes but am
not even going to ask what you have on underneath them.
As soon as
we were all at the tables and our materials appropriately displayed, he
asked IS EVERYONE COMFORTABLE? and then reviewed all the various steps we
would be taking during this court procedure since it was obvious I was not
an attorney and still very prepared and willing to fight for my case. We
will continue this case.
He was very courteous to me. Knowing that
this high profile case on my own, every time there was a lull, he asked me
if I had anything else to present, I did. I presented information about
their profits from killing animals, their lack of training for their
employees, the OBVIOUS: and that was that I was doing all I was doing to
relieve them of taking in those same 200-300 animals during my residence
in Riverside County and felt that they should be thanking me and making
every effort to support me.
Although, I realize it makes
it difficult to continue on with the current fund raising means, when I
would not be able to provide them with any dead animals to sell. I clearly
outlined the facts of why I was doing this because they had not lived up
to their responsibility.
I did what I could to explain that I had
no objection to obtaining a license from the county and agreeing to be
visited by them for periodic check ups. what I didn't agree to and was
simply unable to do was to construct the dog runs that the county required
of me, because I was unable to afford them, was also told by my landlord
that he would not permit them and even then, vowed I wouldn't use them
anyway.
There were three times when I said 'I object' to their
comments and twice it was sustained. YEA!! One 6 occasions, they
interrupted with the same and only on two occasions were they not
overruled. YEA!!
Even the judge questioned the planning and zoning
requirements for building a separate septic system and their requirement
of a $6,000 temporary land use permit. And, since I frequently cared for
more than 15 at any given time, that would place me in the 'business'
category and now would require me to have handicapped parking out front
and also a handicapped bathroom inside my home. The judge actually
chuckled at the county's 8 officials, 2 attorneys and 2 supervisors in
attendance that day.
Bob Buster, one of the remaining supervisors
went to the newspaper and stated ''We all love our animals here in
Riverside County, but Randy Warner is clearly breaking the laws and
refused to abide by the regulations and obtain a license for his kennel.
These laws were set up for the sole purpose of providing for the safety
and well being of the animals until they find their forever
homes.
Remember that man's name
and his comments. It will be a central point of the grand jury
investigation that takes place five years later in which Bob Buster is
found guilty of several of the total of 26 criminal felony charges levied
against the supervisors and animal control. Those who live in glass
houses........
I did, indeed find that people are still good
people at heart and will quickly become involved when a person is being
unjustly wronged and harassed. Sometimes the courtroom had 20-30 people
seated - most were strangers until afterwards when they would introduce
themselves as supporters of my efforts.
On the final two days of the
trials, there were 8 people who paraded around the exterior of the
courthouse with their precious Dalmatians leashed - all to show their
support as well. Here is just a sampling of the letters to the editor that
I collected out of the Press Enterprise and the Los Angeles Times
regarding my battles.
These were all written during my 3 year
battle with Riverside county animal control and board of supervisors. The
public and media sided with me completely. For entire story, go to Media
page and read PRESS ENTERPRISE 'The Story Behind'.
WARNER
SHOULD RUN THE COUNTY ANIMAL CONTROL
My empathy to Mr. Randy Warner
out in Riverside County (Open Forum November 30 regarding Riverside
County’s overpopulation of cats and dogs) I; too had a letter just two
months ago regarding the Riverside County Shelter. (I have great
difficulty using the word shelter as it conjures up the image of comfort
and safe keeping unfairly in this case.) But it is easier to sit back and
just hope that someone else will step up to the plate to solve these and
other problems. Well , finally someone has! The Riverside facility is
under funded, underpaid, under educated and over worked. They cannot even
take in all the animals that come to them on a daily basis without killing
so many innocent ones simply in anticipation of tomorrow’s load
expectancy. Instead of working against this man, they should bring him in
and put him in charge. After all, he’s doing (as just one man) what they
are supposed to be doing BUT unable to do - and all the while, keeps
winning court battles between the two entities. Does no one else see
this? BETTY HUSEBO Los Angeles
KIND AND
COMPASSIONATE
Upon reading about the Dalmatian Rescuer being
fined for not having a kennel license, I believe that instead of fining
this superior person Randy Warner $135, Court Commissioner Jim Bishop
should have sent Mr. Warner a check for $135 to help him with the cost of
the rescuing and taking care of those lucky dogs who find their way to Mr.
Warner’s kind and compassionate care. Mr. Warner is doing what more of us
should be doing – helping those who cannot help themselves, despite the
cold and callous opposition of the magistrates. WALTER C.
CHIPS Newport Beach - WASTEFUL ANIMAL CONTROL
Why is
animal control and now the county board of supervisors bothering Randy
Warner. They should take the estimated $40,000 they’ve spent so far
attempting to convict, but only getting NOT GUILTY verdicts for Warner,
and try to clean up their own facility. The animals there are smelly and
sick. There are already too many unwanted animals in this county. They
should do something to make them more adoptable. Over the past 3 years, my
mom and dad have adopted 2 different Dalmatians from Randy. They always
looked happy and were able to play in the yard or go inside his house.
They have continued to admit that they have not actually been to Randy’s
place, but take the ‘word’ of their officer. They could certainly learn a
lot from Randy. I know we have. LINDSAY FORMAN 13 YRS
Perris
HELP SOMEBODY WHO CARES
I, too am upset and angry at
the tax dollars wasted in Riverside County by self serving bearcats to
pursue Randy Warner, rescuer of Dalmatians. Just drive around anywhere
and see a beautiful, but dead dog along side of a road. So very many
people no longer care about things like this. We have one among us who
does and he’s willing to prove it. Let’s help someone who cares – enough
for all of us! E.J. WALKER Walnut Hills
MISSING THE
POINT…
Taxpayers of Riverside County should be aware of the
relentless pursuit of that dastardly villain, Randy Warner and his band of
fugitive Dalmatians. Animal Control issues a new citation within 48
hours of each court appearance. To get a kennel license, Randy must build
kennels, estimated at $10,000 with no guarantee they would be approved by
the county, plus a $6,000 land use permit – all money he does not
have. Mr. Warner saves thousands of taxpayer dollars rescuing animals
that would be picked up, housed and ultimately destroyed. Those saved
dollars are then paid to attorneys to represent Animal Control ‘stooges’
in court against Mr. Warner. The most recent attorney appeared on May 12.
Her purpose? To request Commission Bishop deny Mr. Warner’s right to plead
not guilty PATSY MUNOZ Riverside
SAVING DALMATIANS
I’m becoming more and more upset about reading of the endless
persecution of Randy Warner in Riverside County who is rescuing
Dalmatians. There are so many laws on the books that are never enforced,
so why in the world would the county supervisors continue the relentless
efforts to try and obtain a conviction on Warners good deeds? (a
conviction in this case could bring as much as a $100 fine; an infraction)
Not only lacking in common sense, but seemingly unenforceable by the
county or Warner wouldn’t continue to be victorious in the courtroom for
several years now. Warner never gets a day off, not even Christmas or
Easter, as these dogs must be fed and watered and cleaned up after 7 days
a week without fail. So, how in the world could Commissioner Bishop
require a bail from this man, with no criminal record, who has sacrificed
his pence, freedom and normality of life, in order to save all these
innocent Dalmatians? This is becoming a farce for the ‘HILLBILLY
MAFIA” or County supervisors to fight until they win. It’s called the male
ego. In other words, the least likely person in the county to run away or
become a flight risk!! Money he does not have. I’m sick of bearcats
wasting my money in a futile attempt to enforce a law that most have never
heard of, had nothing to do with making and agree it should be removed
from the books. Leave Randy Warner alone!! Don’t fire him, don’t jail h
im, don’t harass him. He’s the closest thing we have to a saint here in
Riverside County! NADIA WEST Murietta
DEFINING A
HERO
Randy Warner and his Dalmatian Rescue continues to fight city
hall. He continues to be cited and will once again appear in court in
Riverside County while the taxpayers will be charged with paying the legal
representation of the county board of supervisors just for their futile
attempt to ‘’be right’’. On August 24th, the board meets to change the
kennel laws. What is now an infraction becomes a misdemeanor. What is now
a maximum of $100 fine, will then become a $1,000 fine and carry a six
month jail term if found guilty. They admitted in an article from the
Press Enterprise that this was another attempt to bring the importance of
this issue to Randy Warner. He is continuing to fight for the lives of
these otherwise unwanted animals and has, up till now, been within the
laws – until they change them to spite him. A hero? Any man who would go
to these measures and stay within the law in spite of the circus
atmosphere the county has brought upon this case, is truly nothing short
of one. He’s willing to give all he has for his beliefs. Good for
him.
R. A. TEMBLEDORE Pasadena
WRONG APPROACH FOR
RESCUER
It amazes me how time and again, a judge makes his or
her decision based on zero logic. We have a man among us, whose compassion
and love for these unwanted and unloved Dalmatians, knows no bounds. At
least that anyone has seen yet. Yes, he devotes 100% of his time to
training and caring for these unbelievable numbers of Dalmatians, in hopes
they will someday find the home that will keep them and love them as it
should be. But, no he doesn’t have the money to construct the expensive
and unnecessary constraints and kennels required to satisfy the county
officials who are bound and determined to show they are right in this
case, but have not been able to in over 3 years. Shame on the bully
commissioners for punishing Mr. Warner for what he is doing. Even the law
agrees with him over the past few years. They should present him with a
plaque awarding him top honors for standing alone and fighting for the
lives of these dogs. My husband and 2 children and I took a ride over the
weekend to drive past the place we’d heard so much about. Not only did he
invite us in, but the amount of love we experienced in these dogs who had
just faced certain death, just floored us. They were a mass of moving
spots to us, but each one has a name and personality that Randy knows
intimately. He has obviously been victorious over these years because he’s
doing things right. Too bad the ignorant commissioners can’t see
that. DEBORAH MORRIS RUSS West Hollywood
The end results
of my standing up for the animals:
The entire mixture of events
and introductions throughout my years of doing rescue provided me with
many opportunities to meet people who could and would assist in my defense
later on. For testimonies, I called Sharon Cody, the mayor of Mission
Viejo as well as two other animal protection organizations'
directors.
|
This notoriety also
brought invitations to attend an animal rescue event in Las Vegas
during the same weekend that I would be accompanying 24 of my
Dalmatians to Caesar's Palace Hotel; and Casino for the Labor Day
Telethon where Firefighters posed with my dals for a calendar that
would later be auctioned off for Jerry's Kids. |

|
The folks who planned the
entire event promised that my dogs and I would be picked up and brought to
Las Vegas from southern CA in luxury. Sure enough, a beautiful luxury bus
owned by Caesars' Palace pulled into my driveway at 8 am for the return
trip to Vegas. We decided to stop in Barstow to get everyone lunch -
including the dogs - each of which were served one small order of fries
for being so well mannered while in the vehicle for the long trip. We were
driven to the front door of a lovely home owned by a couple who offered
their home to use for out stay since they too had Dalmatians living there
and thought it would be an experience. We backed the bus into the
driveway, opened their garage door and ran back to the rear of the house
and everyone followed without even hesitating. This can also be seen in
more detail by going to www.21stcenturycares.org/vegasphotoshoot.htm
But I believe that the largest honor bestowed upon the dogs and
myself was when we were invited to participate in the 1997 Tournament of
Roses Parade in Pasadena and walk along side the float for the California
Antique firefighters Association. Just about the center of town, I was
asking myself why in the world I'd agreed to go along on this overwhelming
parade route, as I'd marched in it in my younger years as well. So, I was
very aware of the seemingly endless crowd of spectators that line the 5
and 1/2 mile route.
|

|
One week prior to the
release of their second live action feature film starring
Dalmatians, Disney's Main Headquarters in Burbank was the host of a
press conference to plead with the management to keep their promise
and provide some information prior to every film' showing in an
effort to reduce the large numbers of impulse puppy buying that took
place during the first movie release. On both occasions,
several groups of animal lovers had been promised that this would
happen. However, for the first release, there was no notice at
all. We weren't expecting an educational segment to a Disney
classic, but we also didn't expect to be lied to by the management
quite like we were
either. |
|
So, In Defense of
Animals invited The president of the Amanda Foundation of Los
Angeles and myself to speak out front of the Disney Complex and then
attempt to make a personal delivery of a letter stating our concerns
up to the office of Michael Eisner, the president. Wow. ABC, CBS,
NBC, Fox, Clear Channel Radio, MTV, ETV , Rueters and AP were all
there to cover the event. |

|
As I put my dogs back into
the van to drive home, it was already airing on one of the radio news
broadcasts. Then, while they were 'on' the story, MTV and ETV both came
out to my place to show an example of Dalmatian Rescue since I had 42 at
this particular time. You can read the story in LA Times that covered this
event by logging onto http://www.21stcenturycares.org/pressconf.htm
The entire thing seemed so out of place and oddly coordinated to
me. Here I was continuing with my 'troublesome' behavior and battling with
officials about the need to rescue these poor animals and once again,
facing jail time.
|
As the court dates
began to increase and continue on, I would exit the courtroom and
enter an interested and sometimes agitated pool of reporters from LA
TV stations, major Southern CA newspapers and even a radio station
or two who were all covering my story. |

|
You see, as the trials began
to gain momentum in the media, they were more often than not, barred from
entering at all. Just made me feel like a hero for doing something good,
but in an illegal fashion. I soon learned that the impact I would
ultimately have on the concept of humane education in our nation would
absolutely make up for any troubles I had caused the various county
governments.
As the end of these hearings in Riverside County
neared, I realized that I had been featured in front page news stories
several dozen times in Los Angeles Times and the Press Enterprise
publications and literally hundreds of other papers across the nation via
Associated Press who covered several of the more publicized hearings.
Printed materials included People Magazine, USA Today and several other
national magazines.
|
|
Additionally appeared
on the Leeza Gibbons Talk Show three times during all this and was a
special guest on Richard Simmons 'Dream Maker' TV show as well. Hard
Copy did a story on the trial, as did CBS Evening News. The best of
all was when George Lucas' film company asked to come out to my home
in Menifee and get some footage on what it was I was trying to
do. |
That was ultimately edited
to become the video documentary 'Trouble Spots' which is available on my
website www.21stcenturycares.org/troublespots.htm
Most shocking of all was
when the NHK Network out of Tokyo Japan requested permission to bring a
film crew to do similar shooting and an interview. The host of the show
they used my footage on, was Yoshi Taki - the japanese equivalent of our
Tom Cruise I was told. As they all packed up and prepared to leave, the
lady in charge quietly handed me a wad of bills totally $1,000. Just their
way of saying thanks for all I'd done and would likely continue to do for
the animals.
|
Throughout the four
years of going to court over and over, I tried to keep my efforts
very public as well as continuing to adopt as many Dalmatians as
possible by doing as many special events as I could schedule. We
took 44 Dalmatians and participated in the Mission Viejo, and also
Pasadena St Patrick's Day parade with all the Dalmatians having
GREEN polka dots for the celebration. On both years we entered, we
were awarded the first place trophy for our entry.
|

|
For two of the summers we
had our own booth at the LA Childrens' Fair and passed out information,
adopted a few to good homes and received some nice donations to continue
our work. I was given four tickets to the premier of the Disney release of
their new live action 101 DALMATIANS. That was a very fun evening for 3
friends and myself. It was a typical Hollywood premier with the red
carpet, lights and limousines out front.
We were also invited to
be the ''good luck charms'' at the California Builders' Association's
annual black tie/casino night at the Four Seasons Hotel in Newport Beach.
Before gambling, the guests were invited to rub the dogs for good
luck.
|

|
The Anaheim Hilton
invited us to be part of the 50-'s night in their main ballroom. So,
we custom made their little 'people skirts' and had little saddle
shoes tied in place as well as the scarves around their necks. they
looked like Laverne and Shirley. the Elvis impersonator for the
evening was so impressed with them that he invited them on stage
while he entertained the audience for the
evening. |
We've all heard the saying,
'NEW YORKERS HAVE SEEN EVERYTHING!” Well, I must admit that I surprised
even the most seasoned veterans of the metropolis when I paid a visit in
98. I would still place this particular trip to New York City with my two
'girls' as well as two rescue dogs in my care as being the most amazing
thing I may have ever done.
I was called to appear on
'Late night with David Letterman'. He requested that I scour the local New
York area animal facilities and search for any and all Dalmatians which
were adoptable on that given day to see if the problem was truly
nationwide. His staff would pay for any and all adoption fees, pay for
transporting the animals to Central park with the appropriate handlers,
parking and even a lunch voucher.
I found, and adopted 47
Dalmatians that day and each one of them arrived at Central Park the
following morning at 9am. where I got to know more about the dogs, allowed
them to play and exercise and then we began our long walking journey from
Central Park, down 5th Avenue at noon for 26 New York City Blocks for the
4:30pm taping of the show. Within about 8 blocks we were stopped by the
police suggesting to us that we allow them to block off one lane of
traffic in the streets and allow the pedestrian traffic to continue
unobstructed by our army of handlers and Dalmatians.
|
While we waited,
a priest came out of St Patrick's Cathedral asking what the special
event was. When we explained that we had just saved all these dogs
from certain death, he invited us to step into the vestibule of the
church and gave us a formal blessing. |

|
|

|
We then continued on
to Rockefeller Center where we purchased Soft Pretzels for each one
of the dogs. When we arrived at NBC building, I was surrounded by
security, press from the New York City papers and TV news as the
producers escorted the parade of spots to the elevators that took us
to his studio. |
|
David Letterman was
floored to see the results of my one day adoptathon. Through the
efforts and generosity of David Letterman Show, 39 of the Dalmatians
found [permanent homes through a hotline he had set up. The
remaining 8 dogs were accepted by a Connecticut Dalmatian Rescue
Organization so they could place them as well. |

|
Above are my two as they try
to host the
show. Below, they address the NYC Kiwanis Club Luncheon
|

|
During our 6 day stay
in New York City, I also was asked to speak at a Kiwanis Club
meeting downtown at the Hyatt one afternoon and they made it clear
that my Dalmatians were very welcome to attend the special luncheon.
Of course they did and proudly wore their best bowties to the
event |
As I am now becoming more of
a folk hero for all the Los Angeles basin, I was invited to bring all 27
of my Dalmatians to the Federal building on Wilshire and the Santa Monica
freeway and this nice couple would make all the arrangements for me to
hold a nice adoption fair one Saturday afternoon. The host
organization provided everything out of their own pocket. 'New Leash
On Life' organization in Los Angeles.
It was marvelous. clowns for
the kids, a hot dog stand, a radio station and three big fire trucks were
on site. After speaking to a pair of women about my ongoing fight in the
neighboring county, they both said, they'd heard so much about me and now
they were totally convinced that they needed to step in to help. Kathy
Riordan was one of them. She is the daughter of the 'then' mayor of Los
Angeles, Richard Riordan. A week later, she placed this article in the Los
Angeles Times regarding the entire waste of time and efforts;
It is
clear to me now, that this media attention is in large part responsible
for the favorable outcome to this whole thing. I suggest that everyone who
does rescue to any extent, try and get their local paper and TV station to
come out and cover your efforts occasionally - especially when you attend
the classroom for presentations. The media loves photos with children and
pets. This gives your organization much public attention as well as
credibility when standing in front of a court of law.
JUST KILL THE
DOGS by Kathy Riordan (Los Angeles Mayor Riordan's daughter)
A
sad reflection upon our current society. Randy Warner of Dalmatian ResQ in
Riverside County is one who should be made into a hero and not criminally
prosecuted. Even the general 'man about town' is unaware of all that is
taking place;
Throughout every city and state across the country,
those who demonstrate volunteerism and good citizenship are highly
valued. By supplementing what would otherwise be the full
responsibility of local governments, these individuals fill the gaps
left by skeleton staff. They withstand undue pressure to do the
impossible, and are threatened by downsizing and insufficient funds
needed to maintain quality services or even properly execute
mandate.
The kill rate in most counties across the nation is
embarrassingly high and is one of the worst examples we continue to
set for our future generations to come. These agencies, along with the
county and municipal governing bodies, could and should view these
volunteers and rescues as 'assistants' who help out for no pay or
compensation whatsoever.
Instead, when a good citizen steps
forward to save the lives of hundreds or even thousands of companion
animals, including dogs and cats who would otherwise become staggering
statistics, he/she is met with incredible and very encumbering fees,
regulations and rules, legal threats and more.. This, while over 8
million adoptable pets are to be killed each year in this country, and
backyard breeders choose to have a recreational litter of kittens or
puppies with almost no regulation, guidance or structure at all. Yet,
they are the people who are clearly the contributing factor in this
problem. Again we see the "without victims" theory coming into play; in
this case, animal control agencies would loose many jobs. This is
mainly due to a seriously inadequate understanding by Americans as to
the results of their actions.
Animal control agencies that have
a highly questionable record of humane performance and fail to 'market'
their commodity as a normal business would allow this to
continue with no thought of any tomorrows. Poor business hours for
adoptions and retrievals of lost pets, fall short in reminding their
public of the pets who are adoptable on a widespread, regular basis,
frequently unwilling to require mandatory spay neuter to any pet going out
the door. Most of the problems stem from a lack of understanding within
the community of the restrictions and requirements placed on the
underpaid, overworked and under educated animal control staff. It becomes
a vicious circle. But, it's all becoming much more clear recently. The
'lip service' we hear from everyone else is a cover up for their
ignorance and refusal to be responsible caring citizens.
Law
enforcement agencies, large numbers of elected officials and a surprising
majority of our citizens have no respect for the lives of these innocent
animals or these things would clearly have been looked into and dealt with
accordingly. This also means they refuse to properly acknowledge the
proven impact that conditions and actions have on the future generations
of children who fall victim to having parents with little or no patience
for the obvious. And the subsequent results are allowed to contaminate our
future generations with the same disrespect as many other like situations
that were quickly outlawed and strongly governed.
We need to be
smart. We need to change the way we view and teach the world in a very
different way. Not similar to what we've done for 60 years, but
differently - a way that works. We need to prove to the legislators at
all levels that even though animals don't vote or contribute to
campaign re-elections, WE DO! And we should do it volume. Ask each and
every person running for office about their views and plans for
improvements, and hold them to it
So, when:
- our
congressmen and women, senators and assemblymen drag their feet and
vote “no” on important animal legislation,
- law enforcement
continue to claim a lack of time and resources is their justification for
not making appropriate arrests,
- the judges are refusing to
uphold current laws by offering lighter sentencing and dismissing charges
completely and
- the local governing bodies are giving themselves
up to 35% pay increases annually
- all this, while cutting the
animal control budgets,. they are sending a message that America
hears.
Until further notice, the general public and lawmakers are
sending a strong message, and it is coming through loud and clear –
JUST KILL THE DOGS!! ===============
The previous article could
run in any major paper in America and strike a chord. Almost every week,
somewhere in America, an animal collector/hoarder situation is raided,
often requiring the rescue of hundreds of animals at a time. Often the
media, the authorities, and the rescue community condemns and accuses. We
are so accustomed to being betrayed by our society and government that we
have little tolerance for being betrayed by one of our "own."
The biggest reason for
being turned into the pound in America is because people didn’t do what
was necessary to get the dog to be appropriately behaved. The second
reason is that the humans were moving or found it inconvenient to live
with the dog in their lives. This ultimately guarantees these dogs will
die. With the number of unwanted animals our nation’s facilities are
forced to accept, there is no alternative, but to kill up to 80% of all
incoming animals. Many within hours of their arrival. Yet we continue to
have litters and be unrealistic in our desires of how we expect our
animals to behave with no professional training or even the appropriate
care. Is that a society who honestly loves dogs?
Here we are 7 years after my
battle with Riverside County idiots. Since then, there have been 3
county investigations into the board of supervisors and even a grand jury
investigation finding 28 felony criminal charges against the animal
control as well as Bob Buster and several other supervisors in 2003.
Now, in the March 11 Press Enterprise, it was reported that not one single
requirement from the grand jury investigation has been implemented.
As a matter of fact, employment has been reduced due to budget cuts and
they kill more dogs than ever. Oh, and yes, the supervisors have
voted themselves yet another pay increase. This time it was 35%
annually. The Riverside County residents could care less. Too
many politics with what used to be LEAF and other groups simply being
ignorant and unwilling to step up to the plate.
In Europe, with it's
no-kill shelters, euthanasia is only administered by veterinarians and
only by lethal injection. Their strict licensing, animal control and
welfare laws, and national databases of convicted animal abusers and
neglecters put American's laws and actions (or lack there of) to shame.
There is no lip service there, but a genuine love and responsibility
taught and expected from every citizen.
They don’t have
collectors or hoarders. There is no need for an overload of rescue
organizations. They truly understand their place and the animals’
place.
We cannot say that about
North Americans. We’ve created a prevailing system of apathy and
ignorance, where shelters and volunteer rescue efforts cannot possibly
stem the tide, where government has mostly turned its back on animal
welfare and control efforts, where anything "animal" is usually paid ‘lip’
service (always said softly, bottom lip protruding in that tone of voice
that denotes sympathy or pity) and then, given the lowest priority, where
animals often die horrible deaths, where local animal rescue organizations
can barely fund the resources they provide to "crisis" situations, and
where a lot of people, as well as the major humane organizations are
making MILLIONS AND MILLIONS from animals.
Americans believe they
can buy their way out of any situation. “I’ll do what ever I please, then
when it catches up to me, I’ll just buy my way out”. That is exactly why
the national organizations are rolling in the dough. We send funds out of
guilt and out of pity. Then refuse to do the right thing the rest of the
year by speaking out, altering pets and helping the local situations that
we can more closely monitor.
I get a lot of mail each
week and often from rescuers who are out of hope and out of funds. They
sometimes describe personal situations to me that worry me, and they ask
me if I have any suggestions of help for them. Then everything I suggest
is something they just couldn’t imagine trying. I've even angered some
Rescue efforts with criticisms (largely borne of frustration), because
their efforts and websites and fundraisers and other events include NO
advocacy and education components.
That means we will
always be forced to deal with the status quo, rescuing animal by animal,
with no end in sight (and where I'm often "wrong" is that's still better
than nothing!). The next generation will be doomed to spending time and
money rescuing to a similar degree. We will NEVER save all the animals who
need help. There will be that given percentage which cannot be reached in
time. If each rescuer were to take 20% of their time and resources and
went to the local schools, we could ALL see a reduction of the need to
follow in their footsteps in our lifetimes! So, for every rescuer who is
spending all their time and resources on rescuing animals and not
addressing the cause of these problems to their local ‘masses’, I ask you
to view this more from the standpoint of a business.
For every
"accomplishment" we cheer about, some other situation or decision by
government seems to take us two steps backwards. One more reason I added
'PROJECT VOTE SMART" to this site. You need to know where your
representatives stand on the local and area animal issues, let them know
you are voting accordingly and let your voice be heard. For evil to
prevail, good people need to do nothing.
Of course nobody wants
to see the animals suffer. No one adopts a pet for the fun of taking it to
the pound to watch it die. Yet, we watch and still do nothing and we take
nearly a thousand pets to the pound every day in this country - few for
any justifiable reason. (“moving”, ‘don’t have time”, not right for the
kids”) etc.
With that said,
education does make the most sense. It changes people's perceptions of
what is happening, what they can and can't do in order to prevent further
pain and anguish and death among our animal friends. I've seen it change
teen lives right in front of me.
If we could get America
and Canada to "no kill" as soon as possible, if we could outlaw every
method of "euthanasia" except by lethal injection
(http://www.crean.com/kindness), if we could get every animal lover in the
country to write a letter to an editor on an animal issue, and demand that
our media report on those issues, and hold government at all levels
accountable for, at the least, animal control and welfare issues - we
could see such improvements, stop creating "collectors" and maybe we could
negate the need to rescue hundreds/thousands of poorly cared for animals
at a time, who further deplete rescue resources.
Then, as you read
in the story regarding my on going battle with County officials, I began
to look into some things. With True Ignorance of how the laws will be
enforced and by whom...... I now have a good friend who is a Paralegal,
Animal Control Officer, Law Enforcement Officer,, Humane Educator, and a
number of other things. Being in Animal Welfare, we feel like questioning
the value of humans quite often. I have done many things in my short adult
life and I want to ponder and propose in an effort to make people
think….So, pardon me if I seem to ramble…
I’ve been front line and
reinforcement for animal issues. I have seen the large national
organizations do nothing and I’ve seen single individuals move mountains.
I know that government is being forced to legislate, moderate, and enforce
more than ever. The problem I don’t understand is why any agency (public
or private) is willing to create legislation and rules about and for
animals, yet they don’t understand the first thing about
animals.
Let’s look at
legislators for a moment. It really doesn’t matter if they are federal,
state, or local municipalities. There are laws on the books about dogs and
cats across this great Nation. But, do the people who are writing the laws
understand animal behavior? Some legislators do look to their local animal
welfare agency for guidance….but do they know? Does the local humane
society know? Do the local vets know? A vet may know how a cat behaves in
a stressful situation, but do they know how to write a law to protect that
cat?
Humane Societies are
helpful, to an extent….they know about the overpopulation problem, and
they surely appreciate the stupid reasons people dump their pets, but do
they know what an animal control officer faces in the field? Can an animal
control officer adequately convey to the legal department what needs to be
included in the actual legislation? We must all pull together and share
our information in order to create good, powerful legislation. The
attorneys can put all the jargon together, but what use is that, if they
don’t know or appreciate the need on the street?
Unfortunately, many
animal control officers are without professional training (and they’re not
attorneys) so they are usually unable to create the verbiage necessary for
such a task. When creating legislation, animal behavior MUST be
considered. If you’re going to hold a dog responsible for biting a human,
should the human bitten also be held responsible? Every weathered animal
control officer will agree that the person responsible for the dog should
be held responsible!!
Every good and
knowledgeable citizen SHOULD feel the same way. Each case is individual
and is cause for investigation. Each case ought to be examined by someone
who understands animal behavior. If a person tries to take food out of a
dog’s mouth, is it unreasonable to expect the animal to allow it? (I’m not
talking common sense stuff, my dog would let me and any responsible
owner’s dog would accept that) We’re talking about the people who do not
care for or train their dog….the irresponsible pet owner. If a child trips
over a sleeping dog and the dog bites the child, who’s fault is it? That
is normal, typical behavior for a dog! Where were the child’s parents?
Yes, accidents
happen…..should a life be taken because of it? However, if a child walks
by a dog (no food on the kids face, no sleeping dog situations) is it fair
to let the dog maul the child while no human is held responsible? I’m not
saying euthanize the dog, I’m saying give the owners choices.
I don’t believe in “3
bites your out” type legislation, but I also don’t think that a truly
vicious dog ought to be allowed to terrorize a neighborhood.
Judges are often in this
loop of “uneducated” enforcers. They are not in the street and it’s not
their neighbor’s dog that is keeping them up at 4:00 in the morning. Often
times, they have no regard for animals (especially if you live in Rural,
USA). It’s a dog; they have felons to worry about in over flowing jails. I
don’t care what their excuse is….if they are elected Judges, VOTE!!! If
they are appointed judges, then talk with the person that appointed them
(Often the Governor or Mayor). HOLD THEIR FEET TO THE FIRE AND MAKE THEM
DO THEIR JOB! Animal laws are just as important as human laws! Violence
breeds Violence!
Cops are on the street
to protect the public. Sometimes that protection is from a 400# armed
robber, sometimes it’s from a 150# Rottweiler. They are there to enforce
the laws. It does not matter if that law is a federal law, a state law, or
a local ordinance. They are sworn to uphold and protect. Educate the
police chief and offer to help. Don’t just sit there and criticize….help
them understand.
OK, enough about the
public sector….let’s look at some private issues: Apartment
complexes…..all of us know several apartment complexes that do not allow
pets. The complexes that do allow dogs often have a weight limit of, oh,
we’ll say 20#. I can tell you from experience, the average dog weighs in
at 55#. The complex claims that a small dog causes less damage. Hogwash! A
properly trained dog, no matter what the size, causes no damage! (I’m not
talking about during thunderstorms!). Hold the people responsible, not the
dog! Ok, so a toy poodle will pee less than a Doberman pinscher. Either
way, the carpet is wet and has to be cleaned! If you have a housetrained
dog, that is not an issue anyway!!! Besides, everyone who has a lick of
sense knows that a Great Dane or Greyhound is a much better apartment dog
than a Jack Russell Terrier! Heck, even a Saint Bernard would be better
than a Rat Terrier….it’s what is inside that counts! So why do they have
the stupid weight limit? I’ve never understood that!
Here’s another situation
that dog owners are facing everywhere TODAY! Canceled homeowners’
insurance, inability to renew, or flat rejection for coverage. Why?
Because they have a certain “type” of dog. What type is that, you ask?
BIG! The insurance black list of dogs is growing each day. It includes
Pit-Bull (doesn’t matter which type of pit), Dobermans, Rottweilers, Great
Danes, German Shepherds, Dalmatians, Golden Retrievers…wait! Did I say
“Golden Retrievers”? why, they are the “American Family Dog”! Yes, that is
what I said. Humane responsibility is going down the toilet, everyone
wants to blame someone else. Dogs bite….cats bite….give me the right
reason, and I’ll bite too! Don’t hold the dog responsible, hold the people
responsible. If you have a dog and you’re a responsible owner, you will
see to it that the dog will not bite (under normal circumstances – I WANT
it to bite if someone is coming through my window at 3 a.m.).
Why won’t insurance agencies
just make stipulations for coverage? Basic obedience, sterilization,
socialization…..all those things will help teach a dog how to behave in
polite society. It has NOTHING to do with the breed! So, if you’re
still with me, congratulations!!! I hope I haven’t bored you to tears.
Here is my challenge to you:
Don’t sit on your butt
and complain about all these stupid rules and regulations! Get off your
duff, contact the people who make these statements and educate them! Help
them understand basic animal behavior and why it is in their best interest
to consider animal behavior when they are making these laws. Don’t go in
there with a “holier than thou” attitude because you have the answers;
approach them with a helping attitude. By helping the stupid human, you
help the dumb animal (dumb, like can’t talk, not dumb as in stupid….I’ve
known some really smart dogs! But they still couldn’t talk).
Don’t even get me
started on ‘leash laws’, ‘tied up dogs’ so-called ‘’guard dogs’’ that have
had no training and couldn’t’ save your ass anyway cause they’re OUTSIDE
and penned or tied up – oh I could go on forever. Ask my husband. It
boils down to making PEOPLE be responsible, not punishing animals because
their humans are stupid!
The final straw that broke the camel's
back was when I was trying to show the residents of the area that I
appreciated all their support throughout the nearly four year battle with
riverside county's elected criminal element, so I decided to form an
animal organization to service the needs of that corner of the county.
Lake Ellsinore was the closest branch of the animal control and that was
over 30 miles away. They were very established and had called me 30 or 40
times over the previous ten to 15 years to request that I rescue a
Dalmatian or two that was in their facility.
I always did so. I was
beginning to feel very trusted within the ranks when there. But, when they
found out that I was attempting to form the Temecula Valley Humane
Association, they quickly instructed their attorneys to place a letter in
the paper to clearly separate themselves from our efforts for fear that we
would steal some of their popularity and subsequent donation base. We had
decided, and made it very clear, that we would not be in a situation where
competition would be necessary in any way as we were not planning to build
any facility or have any paid employees.
We would provide education
programs to all the area schools and have an army of volunteers who could
foster any pets that were acquired within our local area until the county
could make arrangements for a pick up. I mean, we made every attempt to
look into the future and was hopeful that we could all work side by side
in an effort to save the animals. But that was not to be. They viewed by
actions as 'being against' them since they are a contracted source of the
county animal services department.
That newspaper article then
seemed to 'cool'' the interests of the area schools as well. Now, I see so
much more as to why the animal movement is so bogged down and
unsuccessful. Egos, Ignorance, Politics, Power and Greed. Since it is such
an enormous means for raising funds from the public, I would say with
confidence that the bickering, bad mouthing and games are at a level that
surpasses most other businesses of today.
Then it became so very clear
to us what was happening. As we announced the planned formation of the
TVHA, we were approached by the ASPCA, HSUS and several other world
leaders in animal protection efforts. Each one trying to convince us to
call ourselves ''the ____ Humane Society'' or in another case '' The _____
SPCA. Most interesting to all of us was their level of convincing - even
monetary donations to help our efforts to assure proper funding. That is
where the Lake Elsinore group feared that we would be butting in on some
of their easy money sources. We made it very clear that we needed no funds
at this time. We also incorporated the organization to read:
We plan to operate no
facility but to make every effort to assist existing local and area
authorities in timely pick ups and appropriate care until they can make
arrangements for the animals pick up. Of the total amount of hours
provided by the team of volunteers we were gathering at monthly meetings
we held at a restaurant's upstairs group room, we clarified that 80% of
our efforts would be directly used for humane education in the area
schools and 2-% of our time would be in caring for the animals on a foster
only basis.
We also set it up to where
it would automatically dissolve itself in the year 2018 - exactly 20 years
from our initial efforts to form were confirmed. Our thoughts were, that
if we were going to be successful in our efforts, we would no longer be a
necessary commodity by the year 2018. And also, that if the residents of
the area were to refuse to take the information and put it to good use,
then there would be no reason to continue either.
Leading to my
next information:
I've even constructed a top ten list. Ten reasons
why money alone will not solve the animal related
problems!!
Today's animal protection efforts come under fire by
various media groups and animal protection organizations. Many within the
ranks are confident that most of the problems we work so diligently on,
could have and should have been solved and corrected years ago, but for
one problem: Human Beings!
With over 3,000 animal
protection organizations in this country, boasting millions of 'members'
and logging an estimated 50 billion man hours since 1979, one must wonder
. So, what's the problem you ask.. After all, We are Americans. If we
honestly wanted this problem to be solved, it would have been by now. No
doubt about it.
If anyone has any honest
expectations of actually seeing changes and truly solving some of the
basic problems that plague our animal friends, then we must make changes.
We can no longer afford to argue our egos, explain away our failures,
defend our agendas and continue to waste billions of dollars to continue
fighting a battle with the same ammunitions that have consistently brought
defeat in the past. It's no secret, that if unified, the animal protection
movement would be the largest lobbying effort in Washington and we would
be able to see many changes.
1 - Most Americans do not know much
at all about the proper care and treatment necessary for a dog or cat to
have the good life they deserve and they refuse to learn. There is no
comprehensive educational program to provide reliable information
regarding proper care and instinctive habits that surface in our pets'
activities.
Most humans misunderstand
their pets actions, refuse to 'listen' to them and only provide the same
treatment as what they witnessed when growing up. Unfortunately that still
holds true today. Their egos seem to win out over compassion and
willingness to be educated. No body asks professionals for guidance, rents
videos or reads websites to get the proper care for their pets because
they refuse to be reminded that they don’t know. The animals
suffer.
2 - Schools continue to
deny offers for humane education - even though most programs are free. And
even though it can and will affect each and every person in that building
sometime during their lives.
Our nations' schools are
so under funded and constantly being driven by test scores, they are
rarely welcoming when organizations offer to bring a humane education
program into their classes - even though a few states have mandatory
humane education laws and many of the humane education programs offered
are at no charge to the schools. These programs have multi-level benefits
to all the young people who attend. When it's brought into the class
through the guidance counselor program of character development, the young
people have higher achievement scores, improved attendance rates and
frequently adopt a less violent conflict resolution technique which leads
to a more compassionate future for everyone.
But, the Animal
Foundation in Las Vegas laughingly argues that they DO provide Humane
Education to their local and area schools and proudly point to the 3 days
they had a volunteer at the school for the mentally handicapped last
season as proof. Of course, the educated reader will ask, 'Well what about
the rest of the 800,000 students in the district? Where was your
organization the other 230 school days?" To which they will have no
answer. We don't think they actually gave that any thought, so we dropped
the subject.
3 -- This brings us to the Large National
Organizations and the fact that most of them are much more interested in
raising money, pointing fingers at other national organizations, avoiding
the real problems, and use the money to money to pay over-inflated
salaries than to actually educate the public or make a true noticeable
difference. But they still know how to 'pat themselves on the back' so
they can rake in another $1 billion of your dollars this year. It's
practically unheard of for them to work together. They seem much more
interested in top billing as opposed to the end results and actual
accomplishments. How far along do you think the space program would be
today if NASA was actually 7 competitive entities who refused to share
their knowledge and combine efforts for a common goal?
We need to point out
that Americans have paid $1 billion in taxes to animal control efforts
annually for the past 20 years and subsequently donated an equal amount of
nearly $1 billion to their favorite animal protection organizations
annually. With that, you would think that we could proudly say ''See all
the problems we've solved" but have we have solved even one thing! They've
made the same promises for 25 years and never kept a single one. But they
can sure take our donations each year with a big smile. Then, blindly, we
give again.
Politics, Agendas, Egos
and Greed tend to lead to the continuing demise of the seemingly noble
efforts. So my first concern is, knowing all this, why haven't the larger
animal organizations taken on a project and SOLVED IT? They have the
manpower, the legislative votes and the financial resources to do so. What
has become of the more than $40 billion from the past 25 years? Like a non
profit Enron. Unfortunately, their primary goals are to keep their
organization financially strong while ignoring the potential they have to
actually do what they've promised their contributors.
After all, if they should
actually solve one or more of the major problems, they would be forced to
downsize, layoff employees and would also be forced to abolish their cute
little pictures of dogs and cats behind bars awaiting certain death - 'the
money shots' as they are called. They spend the billions of dollars we've
given them over the years on over inflated salaries, luxury offices and
even allow millions to simply sit in their bank accounts (per their 2002
IRS Tax returns) to collect interest. Yet, they fail to show any results
or true nationwide success stories.
4 - Animal controls are
notoriously under funded and under educated, yet over worked because of
humans who refuse to be responsible and caring. They are caught in the
middle. The citizens want better animal control, but the agency is never
properly funded by their supervisory boards. . Many animal control
agencies profit from the animals they kill, but the community doesn't know
or won't take proper steps to make the necessary changes. Again, though,
the animals suffer.
5 - The city governments around the nation just
pooh-pooh any animal related upgrades or additional funding. But are quick
to give themselves substantial pay raises on a regular basis. Much of this
comes from simple ignorance as well as greed. They don't even believe in
themselves, let alone the residents in the given jurisdictions. They do
NOT protect the animals, and have the audacity to charge volunteer
rescuers money for every little thing - MUCH of it having little or
nothing to do with the safety and well being of the animals, but
everything to do with trying to prevent rescues from forming and to
squeeze as much money out of them as possible if they do.
6 -
Rescue groups and individuals around the nation work their butts to the
bone, devote most of their lives, spend thousands of their own dollars,
only to waste hours and hours gossiping online to harm other rescuers or
to be back-stabbed by a co-worker, forming modern day witch hunts or be
ram-sacked by animal control officers, and, with no appreciation or even
respect by the majority of the citizens, become bitter and apathetic. Much
too much ego boosting and again, forgetting what their goals actually are
too much of the time. They rarely do more than clean up yesterday's mess -
almost never considering tomorrow.
While these noble
individuals who actually put in all the work get paid nothing - even spend
thousands of their own dollars |